From Playground to Prison Cell: The Kids the System Left Behind
Britain is permanently excluding thousands of children every year, and then acting surprised when they end up in the justice system. This piece unpacks the data, the racial disparities, and the policy failures driving the school-to-prison pipeline.
The Scale of the Problem
Some children walk through the school gates into a future of opportunity. Others walk out of them, but permanently, into something a lot darker. Increasingly, data surrounding this has made an appearance in what journalists call “The School to Prison Pipeline”, and it makes for an uncomfortable reading.
SEN, Poverty and Trauma
In 2023/24, there were 10,900 permanent exclusions from England’s schools. This was a 16% rise from the previous year. But what needs to be honed in on, is that behind these statistics, is a vulnerable child shut out of mainstream education. Children receiving Free School Meals are over five times more likely to be permanently excluded than their peers. Children receiving SEN support (Special Educational Needs) also experience the same odds. Sadly, these are not coincidences, but rather patterns. If you look at the data, the same children appear time and time again.
Children facing poverty already face the heaviest burden at home; combined with unmet needs in the classroom and a complete removal from the educational system, it excludes them from most forms of support available.
The SEN picture is equally as troubling. Research shows that the overwhelming majority of children experiencing school distress are neurodivergent, many of them unidentified and unsupported. Children with special educational needs but no Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan are among the most disproportionately affected by rising exclusions. The education system is punishing children for conditions we haven't yet diagnosed. To simply put it, the system is removing children for behaviours that are often expressed due to unmet needs, whether that at home or in the classroom.
What the data fails to do, it rarely captures the lived experience of these children prior to setting foot in school. We call these Adverse Childhood Experiences. Take for example, neglect and domestic violence. These affect 7/10 children by the age of eight, causing deep social, emotional and cognitive impairment. It doesn’t just go away when entering the school, it walks in with the child every morning, and can appear as defiance. 55% of permanent exclusions are attributed to disruptive behaviour, often caused by reasons mentioned above.
A Racial Divide
There is also the racial dimension that hugely impacts the statistics. Black Caribbean pupils face permanent exclusion rates three times higher than White British pupils. Black children account for 19% of all stop and searches of the under 18 group. At every stage of the system, be that in or outside school, the same children keep appearing in the data, and it’s not a coincidence. It’s because the system is less forgiving of them.
Research on racial bias in the education system (conscious or unconscious) has also confirmed that the same bad behaviours in White children were perceived as much more aggressive and brash in Black children. The same action, a different race, lead to highly different consequences, one of the aforementioned being exclusion.
The system treats both Black children and other racial minorities in Britain differently. Exclusion is where that difference becomes most visible and damaging.
After Exclusion: Where do pupils go?
What comes after exclusion rarely helps. Pupil referral units are essentially the destination for children who have been permanently excluded from mainstream education,
They are state-funded alternative education settings, specifically designed to provide education for children who can't attend a mainstream school due to exclusion, illness, or other reasons.
Who ends up there:
Children with long-term physical or mental health conditions
Children awaiting a place in a new school
Children who have been informally "off-rolled" by schools — removed from registers without a formal exclusion
Young people who are pregnant or new mothers
The Controversy
The statistics around PRU’s are among the most damning in this piece. Approximately 40% of excluded children are attending a PRU, and just under a quarter are not attending any form of provision at all. A quarter of permanently excluded children vanish from education entirely.
The absence rate in PRU’s was 41% percent. Compare this to 7% in mainstream schools. In terms of outcomes for those that do attend, barely 1% of those in alternative provision attained five GCSE’s at grades A* to C. This closes off futures brutally.
A Policy Choice, Not Inevitability
What these statistics, policies and attitudes fail to take into consideration, is that this is not inevitable. It is nothing more than a policy choice. One that is built from underfunded SEND provision, poverty, trauma, and a huge racial variable. It is a policy choice that leaves the most vulnerable children exposed, with a poor alternative provision that does anything but rehabilitate.
The evidence is clear that schools which respond to disruption with support rather than sanction, by this , addressing the root causes of behaviour rather than punishing its symptoms, see far better outcomes for their most troubled pupils. In Barnet, schools that received restorative justice training saw a 51% reduction in exclusions. Until this is built into every school and every PRU in this country, for thousands of kids, the school gate won't be the start of a bright future, but instead a prevention from accessing it.
Sources
Sources
Department for Education — Suspensions and Permanent Exclusions in England: Academic Year 2023/24 — explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statistics/suspensions-and-permanent-exclusions-in-england/2023-24
Ministry of Justice / Youth Justice Board — Youth Justice Statistics 2023 to 2024 — gov.uk/government/statistics/youth-justice-statistics-2023-to-2024/youth-justice-statistics-2023-to-2024
Ministry of Justice — Statistics on Ethnicity and the Criminal Justice System 2024 — gov.uk/government/statistics/ethnicity-and-the-criminal-justice-system-2024/statistics-on-ethnicity-and-the-criminal-justice-system-2024-html
Ministry of Justice — The Evolving Response to Ethnic Disproportionality in Youth Justice — gov.uk/government/news/the-evolving-response-to-ethnic-disproportionality-in-youth-justice
Gov.uk — Prison Education in England: Educational Background, Characteristics and Criminogenic Needs — gov.uk/government/publications/prison-education-in-england-educational-background-and-needs
Office for National Statistics — The Education and Social Care Background of Young People Who Interact with the Criminal Justice System — ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/educationandchildcare/articles/theeducationandsocialcarebackgroundofyoungpeoplewhointeractwiththecriminaljusticesystem/may2022
Office for National Statistics — The Links Between Young People Being Imprisoned, Pupil Background and School Quality — ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/educationandchildcare/articles/thelinksbetweenyoungpeoplebeingimprisonedpupilbackgroundandschoolquality/2023-01-27
Centre for Social Justice — Exclusion Tracker, July 2025 — centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/CSJ-Exclusion_Tracker_Jul25.pdf
Coram Children's Legal Centre — Worrying Trends in School Exclusions, November 2024 — childrenslegalcentre.com/worrying-trends-school-exclusion-statistics
Catch22 — The Prevalence of School Exclusions in the UK — catch-22.org.uk/resources/the-prevalence-of-school-exclusions-in-the-uk
Youth Endowment Fund — Racial Disparity in Exclusions: What Can Data Tell Us? — youthendowmentfund.org.uk/racial-disparity-in-exclusions-what-can-data-tell-us
Institute for Public Policy Research / The Difference — Pupil Exclusions Soar as Black Caribbean and Traveller Students Kicked Out at Higher Rates — newsbreak.com/the-independent-517119/3584622227511-pupil-exclusions-soar-as-black-caribbean-and-traveller-students-kicked-out-of-school-at-higher-rates
British Journal of Criminology — Exclusion from School and Risk of Serious Violence, 2025 — academic.oup.com/bjc/advance-article/doi/10.1093/bjc/azaf015/8051126
British Journal of Social Work — Factors Associated with the School Exclusion Gap for Children with Social Work Involvement, 2025 — academic.oup.com/bjsw/article/55/2/663/7889001
Sage Journals — Preventing School Exclusions of Black Children in England: A Critical Review, Stewart-Hall, Langham & Miller, 2023 — journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/27526461221149034
British Psychological Society — Understanding the Adultification of Children and Young People, 2025 — bps.org.uk/blog/understanding-adultification-children-and-young-people
Parliament — Written Evidence, Prisoner's Education Trust — committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/6266/html
Parliament — Evidence on Alternative Provision (PRUs) — committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/82589/html
House of Commons Library — Racial Discrimination in Schools — commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2023-0049
Gov.uk — Exclusion of Black Pupils Priority Review: Getting it Right — dera.ioe.ac.uk/id/eprint/8656/1/exclusion%20of%20black%20pupils%20priority%20review%20getting%20it%20getting%20it%20right.pdf
Gov.uk Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities — Education and Training — gov.uk/government/publications/the-report-of-the-commission-on-race-and-ethnic-disparities/education-and-training
Race on the Agenda — School Exclusions for Black Caribbean Girls Are Rising Again — rota.org.uk/2024/02/09/pressrelease-new-figures-show-school-exclusions-for-black-caribbean-girls
Women at Wish — The Adultification of Black Girls in the UK — womenatwish.org.uk/the_adultification_of_black_girls_in_the_uk
University of Oxford — We Must Tackle the Mental Health Consequences of Adverse Childhood Experiences — ox.ac.uk/news/2021-07-02-we-must-tackle-mental-health-consequences-adverse-childhood-experiences
London Government — Adverse Childhood Experiences in London — london.gov.uk/sites/default/files/adverse_childhood_experiences_in_london._final_report_october_2019_with_author._mb.pdf
SecEd — Trauma and Adverse Childhood Experiences — sec-ed.co.uk/content/best-practice/trauma-and-adverse-childhood-experiences
Autistic Advocate — Neurodivergent People and the School to Prison Pipeline, January 2025 — autisticadvocate.co.uk/post/neurodivergent-people-and-the-school-to-prison-pipeline
Coventry Restorative Justice — Restorative Justice in Schools — covrj.uk/restorative-justice-in-schools
Structural Learning — Restorative Justice in Schools: A Complete Guide for UK Teachers — structural-learning.com/post/restorative-justice-in-schools